Tuesday, June 4, 2013

The Bobble Head (Part 1)


            Cock Bombay has a boss.  He is a short, forehead-endowed Filipino from Southern California.  I call him the Bobble Head.  With no signs of an accent denoting his nationality, the Bobble Head is all Southern California surf slang.  A real “dude-bro”.  And his head is huge.  There are times when he begins regurgitating some revolting corporate lingo and I am filled with the urge to punch him.  Then I think to myself, “Don’t punch him in the head, it looks very solid.”  His cranium between the eyes and the hairline reminds one of the dinosaur skulls they found that were so thick, paleontologists just assumed they used them for ramming against one another.  If a future alien archeologist ever digs up the Bobble Head’s skull she will probably lament, “this poor chap didn’t have much room for a brain so he must have made a living by running his head through brick walls on bar wagers.”

The Bobble Head is also named thusly because he is the highest paid person in the company that still has to deal with the sales reps on the front lines.  In order to juggle this task, he must alternate his efforts between pleasing his reps and kissing the collective ass of his superiors.  He bobbles one way, he bobbles the other.  His duplicity is one of the more difficult balancing acts in the company and I identify with it.  Just as I, the sales representative, have to navigate the strait between pleasing the customer while simultaneously acquiescing to the demands of The Company, so must he appeal to both Sales Reps and Executives.  The major difference is that I actually care about helping my customers and he can’t wait to shake off the stink of dealing with us.  Over the years, there has been less contact between the Bobble Head and the trenches.  He comes to the store once every 6 months.  As my coworker and accomplice, Brooklyn, points out, “he doesn’t want to see how his sausage is stuffed.” 
He only watches over 8-10 stores, but he dreads visiting each one.  He used to ask, “What do you guys need from me?”  Now, I think he must know better than to open that can of worms.  

But the pressure to win the coveted Customer Satisfaction Award is mounting.  The Execs are challenging one another and it’s Region against Region to see who can get their LTR scores above 60%.  Shit is flowing downhill and I’m keeping clean.  Our focus is on the customer? That’s where I shine.  However, others need more help and it is the Bobble Head’s demeaning task to lead the training session that will help us better serve the customer.  Okay, it's his job to get the numbers up.  
I make the mistake of offering my opinion in this training class:

(cont'd on 6/7/2013)

Friday, May 31, 2013

Service vs. service


To say that a cell phone company’s service drops calls is redundant.  It is the nature of the proverbial beast.  It happens.  Just has you should expect your phone to make calls, so should you expect it to decide that you are done talking before you know it. The technology is always growing, but has never been fast enough to meet the ridiculous claims made to the consumer.  Each cell phone company is digging itself into a hole by offering services and phones they can’t fully support in order to keep up with the competition who is doing the exact same thing. It's feature inflation and the screens on the commercials are always simulated and rarely reproduced. 
In scrambling to keep your attention, the companies disregard your satisfaction.  As long as the customer can be distracted by shiny and new, they will never be given dependable and good.  
When 4G technology came out, one company said they had it.  By definition, no company had it.  But when you have a distrusting clientele, you can't simply say that the competition is lying...the customer will think you're lying. So in 2010, every other company followed suit, ordered posters and ad slots and proclaimed to have 4G technology.  NO ONE HAD IT AND NO ONE DOES.  So excited was an eager public that in December 2010, the International Telecommunication Union changed the definition of what it meant to have 4G technology.  They drastically lowered the standards and allowed every company to pretend they had 4G service.  The current technology is still nowhere close.  But you want 4G, don't you?  And the emperor's clothes are soooo pretty.

Tuesday, May 28, 2013

That Which Gets Measured Gets Micro-managed


Like the DMV and the Airlines, The Phone Company needs only to meet the lowest of expectations to keep customers.  Mergers and consolidations of regional companies over the years have resulted in fewer options for the consumer.  Of every 100 customers who vow to leave their cell phone provider for another, maybe 2 actually do.  Cell phone companies, the DMV and the Airlines don’t need to get out the white gloves for exceptional service. Instead, they are more likely to put on those of the latex variety to test your threshold for pain.  
The DMV knows you have to be there; there is no other DMV.  The Airlines, caught up in price wars that race to the bottom, know that it’s the same bullshit with another company. Plus, you already picked the flight--you can’t really take your business elsewhere at that point.  Or maybe they’re the only company that flies to a specific location.  You don’t really pick an airline based on personnel--you base it on price.  You sacrifice service the second you “sort by price” on the website.  Frequent flyer programs are simply a request for the punisher to whip you where the scars have already formed.  Better the evil you know, and all that.

Every year, I hear The Company talk about improving customer experience.  They sometimes even create job positions dedicated to the task.  Some of the most capable people I’ve met in this company have been hired to enhance your experience at the cell phone store.  I've witnessed innovative minds and kind hearts hired to positions such as Retail Experience Liaison and VP of Customer Loyalty.  Within months, I've seen executives cut them off at the knees.  Funds dry up and Customer Experience programs are closed.  Knowing that customers won't leave anymore than citizens will flee a country following election results, executives play the percentages and know that, in this abusive relationship, you’ll just be back for more.

But wait!  They DO want to fix it!  Believe it or not, there is an award for customer service. There is a piece of hardware that The Company wants more than anything.  There is a golden fleece, a holy grail, a piece of acrylic not yet on the shelf!  It is the J.D. Powers and Associates Award for Customer Satisfaction.  To get it, they must first exceed the cell phone industry’s average rate of customer satisfaction...
...of 61%
...just below that of the DMV.

Because that which gets measured gets micro-managed, The Company has begun to keep track of each sales representative's individual metrics for customer satisfaction.  Following every transaction that takes place inside the cell phone store, the customer receives a survey.  The surveys used to be calls to the home phone, but since we've spent the last decade convincing everyone they don't need a landline, the survey now goes out in the form of a text message.  The survey asks for two things.  Firstly, it asks the customer how likely they would be to recommend The Company to their friends and colleagues.  This Likelihood to Refer, or LTR, quotient is the first question on the survey.  It is asked in a general fashion to assess how the customer feels about The Company.  With the second question, the customer is asked how pleased they were with the individual sales representative who assisted them.  This Individual Customer Satisfaction, or ICS, score is specifically asked to determine the sales representative’s performance.  
These two scores are light years apart.  There are times when our store, located in the troubled cell reception area of Los Angeles, Ca, is averaging a 30% LTR while maintaining above 84% ICS.  Since you're dying to know--I am personally averaging 97% for my individual scores throughout each year.  So 70% of customers are not satisfied with The Company and 3% are not satisfied with me.  I maintain, contrary to the opinion of my supervisors, that I have no control over how the customer chooses to rate The Company.  Whether they say they are likely to refer The Company to friends and colleagues is out of my control.  I have printed up no fewer than 200 surveys over the past year that cite dropped calls, network failure and equipment and rate plan prices as the reason they would not be Likely to Refer the company to others.  
I side with logic, and therefore the customer, on this one.  In fact, I have a hard time respecting anyone who has our company’s cell service and is willing to recommend the product to their friends.  I question their capacity for discernment and their integrity.  It’s like taking a bite of something awful and saying “Ew this is gross! Try this!”  If my customer takes a survey and scores both me and The Company with perfect scores, I immediately assume they are being nice and want me to keep my shitty job.

Friday, May 24, 2013

Mutual Pre-dissatisfaction


“Michelle?”
Michelle turns quickly toward the voice calling her name, dispatches a quick smile and suddenly gets to business as she hastens her gait toward my station.  I greet her personably.  
“How are you doing today?”.  
“Yes, my phone is broken.  The screen finally cracked today.  But before that happened, I want you to know that it has been dropping calls and it barely worked all that well to begin with.  In fact, this phone is defective.  It never worked.  Plus, my bills are over a hundred dollars every month and I feel like I’m paying for service that I don’t even get.  You guys are terrible on the phone.  Have you ever tried talking to customer service?  Ughh.  But nevermind, I need you to replace my phone. Oh, and I never got my $100 dollar rebate from two years ago.”
Who me? Oh, I'm fine, thanks for asking.

Michelle uses the Gatling gun approach at getting her problems solved.  She is hoping that, by accumulation of concerns, one of them will be addressed positively.  She is also making sure that I know that her dropping the phone (sorry, the screen cracking...itself?) should be dismissed in light of the numerous problems she has already endured.  All she really wants to hear at first is one sentence before she can breathe.
“I can help you, Michelle.”

There is an amusing phenomenon that occurs just outside a cell phone store every day.  Before tugging on the handle and walking through the large glass door, the customer breathes in...breathes out...reaches...and enters.  The inhale serves to acknowledge that things will probably not go well.  The exhale is an attempt to accept that fate.  Once inside, a reaction to the customer’s entrance is returned.  The sales rep looks up at the customer, sees an already displeased face....breathes in....breathes out...here we go again.
Do not confuse the chronology of this event with the placing of blame, it's really chicken-or-egg type stuff here.  And the parties are not fighting each other; they are fighting the faceless entities of "policy" and "procedure." But they don't know this and, prepared for the worst, they steel themselves against each other.  I call it mutual pre-dissatisfaction.  This level of it occurs in only a few places.  In fact, I can only think of two other places outside the cell phone store: the Department of Motor Vehicles and the airline industry.  

Example:  In the Summer of 2010, Flight Attendant Steven Slater was arrested for cursing out an airplane full of passengers, grabbing some beer and exiting the aircraft down the inflatable emergency slide.  The escalation went something like this:  
1) Lady passenger doesn't sit down.  
2) Steven insists she does. 
3) Lady passenger grabs bag from overhead. Plane still moving. Bag hits Steven.
4) Steven insists she sit down and leave the bag.
5) Lady passenger calls him a name.  
6) Steven flips out, tells all passengers to "go fuck yourselves!", grabs two Blue Moons, deploys the escape chute and successfully fulfills the dream of every young boy who has ever set eyes on those illustrated safety pamphlets.  

People are dicks on planes.  There’s only so much the dick-handlers can take before they reach capacity and have to throw something back.  Each party has, over time, come to expect the worst in the other.  In fact, these two were both acting on the history of the feud between passenger and flight attendant just as any dutiful Hatfield would treat a McCoy or Montague a Capulet.  Now cell phone stores have joined the limited ranks of places were mutual pre-dissatisfaction occurs.  I work at a place where everyone comes in and thinks, I’m ready to have the worst time of my life, let me sign in and get this over with.


Tuesday, May 21, 2013

Operation Hi-Liter


Operation Hi-Liter is the brainchild of those who occupy the few rungs just below the top of the corporate ladder.  The same people who decided that air-conditioning and seats were a luxury(they stopped letting us sit down in 2005) have also put together this action plan for guaranteed success.  I would feel remiss if I neglected to emphasize and repeat that they've actually titled it “Operation Hi-liter”...as though it equals Desert Shield, or Desert Storm or Dumbo Drop.  
The goal of Operation Hi-liter is to help the customer fully understand what occurs during the sales process.  The logic being that if the customer understands the transaction, they will speak highly of the company.  It is the latest in a long line of strategies to increase customer satisfaction.  Truth be told, these ideas rarely start at the top.  Nothing does.  An idea as asinine as this one started with a store manager somewhere.  Someone at the top later took credit.  
The way I see it happening is that every one is on a conference call.  This conference call, no doubt designed to chew up every ass on the line, finally found some store with positive percentages in the area of customer satisfaction. The VP then asked that manager what they were doing differently and that manager proudly responded, as if it were their doctorate thesis, “we are highlighting every line of the customer’s transaction summary report.”  They probably elaborately lie about how grateful the customer is to have someone dedicate so much time to explaining the phone and service they just bought.  
Success happened here and despite the argument for correlation over causality, the actions will be copied and pasted all over the company.  Never mind the fact that this store only sees 20 customers per day.  Forget the notion that it is a beachfront location with a relaxed clientele.  God forbid we assume these customers at this one store are perhaps just easy-going enough not to want their answers on a survey to be the reason someone gets fired!
The next week, thousands of dollars were spent and thousands of miniature Hi-liters were shipped out to every store on the west coast.  Logic was the only casualty of war during Operation Hi-liter.

So now we sales reps, we soldiers of the Operation, are to don Hi-liters, suspended from lanyards, around our necks.  Anytime there is a transaction with a customer, be it a new phone, a change of text-messaging plans or rate plan adjustment, a receipt prints.  It is then that we are to illuminate the finer points of the transaction.  They never expressly said so, but I believe the tone to use is that akin to teaching a 3 year-old how to finger paint.  “Here’s what we did today--Here’s your name, your number, your plan--Here’s my cell phone number in case you need anything at all...”   
What’s worse, though not surprising by now, is that the supervisors are not checking to see if anyone is using the Hi-Liters, just that we’re wearing them.  Disciplinary action is to be taken if one is found not wearing their Hi-liter.  

I actually stumbled upon an e-mail from a VP requesting “100% participation in Operation Hi-Liter.”  No, seriously.  From a grown man.

I grab my tiny, yellow, illuminating device and return to the sales floor, ducking my head into the lanyard.  There are no fewer than 8 people waiting to be helped.  None of them look happy.  I read the next name from the list.

Friday, May 17, 2013

Cock Bombay


The inside of a retail store manager’s office is a hellish place.  No matter your position in the temporal world of retail sales, you are always trying to escape its caged fluorescence.  Whether you’re the manager who is constantly strategizing his or her way to the next level, or their employee, just trying to get back to work, this space is fleeting--it wants to leave itself.  Any attempts toward improvement can, at any moment, all be placed in a single cardboard box and removed.  This is a place that has no definition or character all it’s own.  It’s the lukewarm that God spits out.

An 8 x 8 afterthought in the corner of the floor plan, this specific office doesn’t even have ventilation.  The door needs to be opened time and again so that its occupants do not die.  At various points throughout the day, from the corner of your eye, you will see the door gasping for air as it is forcefully opened-closed-opened-closed.  Oxygen is violently sucked in and spit out like so many of the workers it temporarily sustains.  There is likely some great corporate design in this.  I think someone was promoted for their brilliant idea of using the threat of impending suffocation to encourage managers to periodically patrol the sales floor.  

Inside, other than the manager’s furniture and palpable lack of oxygen, there are two things every one of these offices should have.  Every store manager should have, within their reach, surveillance and acrylic.  The former to monitor his minions, the latter to remind him how good a job he does at it.  

My distaste for acrylic is a recent development.  I have no good reason but that it decorates the walls of this 64 sq. ft chamber, to hate it.  Logical, if not necessary, in shower doors, aquariums and false nails, acrylic serves its purpose in numerous applications.  In award form, it is cheap.  It is plastic.  It is not significant. It is not valuable.  No one every received their “Longest Streak without a Sick Day Award” at the company picnic and exclaimed “Oh, it’s heavier than I thought it would be!”  If you ever receive more than a handful of these acrylic awards, you should shave the fifth one down to knife form and jam it into your thigh.  

This particular manager’s office is an armory of acrylic.  Two walls are lined with “Most New Phone Line Activations”, “Outstanding Achievement in Accessories” and (lately) “Rockstar of Retail” awards.  There must be 40 plaques and awards (though some are embarrassingly self-produced certificates that still have the printer date/time stamp on the bottom).  
Sadly, the awards are not even given in earnest.  When the Vice President of Sales hands you an acrylic award and says “great job”, he is placating you.  Your acrylic award is your official pat on the head.  I don’t mean to discourage anyone who has received one of these tokens.  Surely, you should be proud of any accomplishments in your job or career.  But when it comes to acrylic in the retail world, you don’t want it weighing you down.  Never accumulate more than you can fit in that cardboard box, or you’ll never escape your acrylic cage.  One or two of these is a sign you’re headed in the right direction.  Twenty of these means you’re already buried.

The subterranean man standing beside the desk has his name etched into every one of these awards.  “Cock Bombay.”  Cock Bombay is not a real name, of course.  Cock Bombay has earned this moniker because he is short, struts around like a rooster, and is from Bombay, India.  Oh yeah, and he’s kind of a dick. 

He asks me to sit down as he walks around his oversized leather chair, placing his hand on its shoulder.  He takes a deep breath, puffing up his chest as he reads his own name on one of the plaques.  “So, Mr. Jason.”  He exhales while pulling the chair back and slowly slinking in.  He breathes again and begins to thoroughly rub his face as if the answers are under his skin.  He closes his eyes dramatically and tilts his head back.  He opens them on the ceiling tiles.
“Customer was very upset.”
“Yeah, I know.”  I am already agitated by this routine and I am quick to respond.  He’s milking the drama as the line of customers is growing outside.
“Do you know why customer was very upset?”
“Yes.”
“Why do you think customer was very upset?”
“Because she has unrealistic expectations that could not be met.”
Hands to face, he rubs, searching.  He gives me that what-are-we-going-to-do-with-you sigh.
“Put it to you this way,” he butchers and pauses again, “customer is not always right.”  
I cautiously agree.  The other foot should be on its way.
He continues, “but at the bottom of the line, the customer must be right.  The customer is boss.  Without the customer, there is no job.  Make sense?”
I nod.  Make sense.
He stands up.  He is wearing a mustard yellow shirt with a tie his wife left out that matches as well as orange can possibly match mustard(Tupperware and the '70's tried this once).  His torso is short.  He ties his tie so that the fat front falls equal to the narrow back.  Even then, and with his greatest efforts of leaning back, protruding his chest, the tie still falls just bellow his belt.  He grabs his belt and tugs on it, less to pull it up and more to recruit it for moral support.  His pants are pressed, his shoes are shined.  He is well-presented.  His hair is always unimaginatively coiffed.  It fades up the sides to a predictable 1.5 inch slicked-but-spiked top.  His dark brown skin makes the false smile stand out but somehow supports his intense, deep brown eyes.
He breathes again slowly, but then builds up speed for an inspirational finale.
“It may be goddamn hard sometime, but we have to remember who pays the bill.  I bet you my job, if you take care of the customer, she will come back and buy from you.  If customers happy, the wolume will be there.  The customers will be back.”
It’s not on every v-word that the upper row of teeth fail to buzz the lower lip, it’s only a select few.  “Wolume” comes up in every sales meeting that mentions our numbers.  It's one of my favorites.
“Got it?”
Got it.
He’s as ready as I am for this meeting to end.  Air is precious and we must resurface.
“Go on.  Go make money.”
“You mean take care of the customer.”
“That’s my guy!” He chuckles before realizing, “Oh! and take your hi-liter.” 
“My what?”  
Then, “oh, yeah” as I hang a hi-liter around my neck.

Wednesday, May 15, 2013

"You don’t understand; my life is in that phone.”


"You don’t understand; my life is in that phone.”  

Her lips tremble, but her eyes sharpen.

“What’s wrong with it?”  

She's straddling the line between being 'scared' and being 'rude'.

Sensing this one is close to the edge, I remind her, as gently as I can, that “when electronics get wet, they often don’t make it back.”  She insists there must be something I can do.  There is nothing I can do.  I have taken the initially offered phone, with visible liquid misting and beading up underneath the front screen, and have tried my best.  I have grabbed three different power sources, popped in three different batteries (each producing the same misleading “red light of almost”).  
I take the back off, grab a T6 screwdriver and dismantle the body just to say “hmmm” and have her eyes widen and lips scream “WHAT...WHAT?  WHAT IS IT?!?!?”.  
“Nothing.”
“Nothing? What do you mean, ‘nothing’?  What about all my information?  All my e-mails, all my contacts?”
“You said you never backed them up on any computer?” I try to help by possibly jogging her memory.
“Nope” her lips sputter as her eyes close again, incredulous that I would ask.
“Hmmm.” 
“There must be something you can do,” she insists.  There is nothing I can do.  She goes on. “This must be some kind of joke,” and then, looking around “aren’t you the Phone Company??”
I confirm her whereabouts as I resist the urge to remind her that I am simply one guy working for the Phone Company.   
“I can’t believe you can’t do anything.  Let me talk to someone who can do something.”
There it is.
I let the accusation of my impotence roll off me as I straighten my back and put the phone back together.
“Miss, there’s nothing that anyone here can do.”
“You don’t understand; my life is in that phone.”
“I’m sorry.”
“I can’t believe you’re not going to help me.”
“Miss, I’ve helped you as much as I possibly can.  We tried.”
She cries...then continues,
“And you’re just standing there like an idiot!!” 
“Miss, there’s no need for that.  I’ve explained all of your options.  I apologize that you are not satisfied with any of our solutions.  You never backed up your contacts so there’s really no way of getting them back.  I don’t want to assign blame here, but I don’t think it’s fair that you accuse me of being anything less than helpful.”

“Are you fucking kidding me!?  MY FUCKING LIFE IS IN THERE!!!!”

“Then your life is very small.  

And wet.”